I would be interested to see the movie with the "silent space" soundtrack, from a curiosity standpoint.
But I'll never buy it, because it's a terrible, terrible movie. For a movie with such an enormous budget and the resources to do things right technically, the completely bogus treatment of simple physics is unforgivable. It was so distracting that it ruined the movie. Never mind the more esoteric aspects of orbital mechanics that it also gets wrong -- the pivotal scene with Bullock and Clooney and the tether just made no sense at all. I actually had a non-technical friend lean over to me and say, "Why the heck would that happen??"
Add to this the buffoonish and unrealistic clowning behavior by the astronauts at the beginning of the movie, the outrageously stilted dialog with ground control (featuring Ed Harris, who clearly knows how deliver a believable mission control performance, as he did in Apollo 13), and you have a train wreck of a movie that was totally undeserving of the Oscar attention that it got. It has a few minutes of eye candy, and a couple of technically impressive special effects shots, and that's all it has to offer.