Multiple Screens, Video Noise, Plasma Choice

Fanatic Fans
We are currently in the process of setting up a home-theater room with one projector and three 32-inch TVs, and we want to be able to watch four different sports channels at the same time. Do we need four separate cable boxes to do this, or can something else, such as some kind of matrix, solve the problem?

Rachel Boone

I know of no such integrated solution. AT&T U-verse advertises the ability to record up to four different shows at the same time and play them on any TV in the house, but as far as I can tell, it can be on only one TV at a time. Also, I've heard many complaints about U-verse, and I don't know if it's even available in Canada, so that's probably not the right solution for you.

I just wrote about Runco's WindowWall on UAV, which would give you this capability in a tiled, in-wall system, but it's expensive, and it wouldn't integrate your projector. Otherwise, I think your best bet is to install multiple cable boxes, though managing their operation with multiple remotes or a universal remote will be a challenge.

Take Out da Noize
I'm curious about why video noise is still an issue with Blu-rays. I've noted this problem with the two HDTVs I've owned (Sony KDS-50A2020 and Panasonic TC-P58V10), and neither one has sufficient noise reduction to deal with a problem I consider more that annoying. I especially notice it in dark scenes and scenes with large areas of solid colors. My PS3 has noise reduction for DVDs but none for Blu-rays.

Is it bad luck that I've purchased TVs and players that are not able to handle noise, or is this a problem that all systems suffer from. Without having to buy a new TV, are there any Blu-ray players with good noise reduction that still provide a good picture? Or is there another suggestion you could offer?

Aaron Butz

I'm willing to bet that what you're seeing is not noise, but film grain, which is endemic to anything shot on film and particularly noticeable in dark scenes and areas of solid color. DVD doesn't have enough resolution to encode film grain reliably, but Blu-ray does, and many studios retain the grain to maintain a filmlike image. (Hey, I'm a poet and didn't know it!) Some titles have had the grain removed, but the image is much more videolike, which most movie buffs object to.

In our experience, very few Blu-rays have actual noise problems; movie reviewer David Vaughn cites Full Metal Jacket as one, but he couldn't come up with other examples off the top of his head. I'm afraid there's not much you can do to eliminate film grain, at least not without seriously harming the picture in other ways.

Plasma Dilemma
Is the Samsung PN63B550 or PN63B590 a good choice for a large plasma in light of the Panny issues? I have a Pioneer Elite PRO-151FD, and I'm helping a friend get the next best thing.

Milt Harvey

We haven't reviewed either of these model lines, so I can't say for sure. The last Samsung plasma we reviewed is the PN50B860, which Tom Norton liked overall, through the black level was pretty disappointing. I want to continue recommending Panasonic plasmas, but I just don't know if the 2010 models will overcome the rising black-level problem. I wish I had a definitive plasma recommendation, but at this time, I don't.

If you have a home-theater question, please send it to scott.wilkinson@sorc.com.

COMMENTS
Darren Imada's picture

I am finally finishing the renovation on my home, but I have "missed the boat" on installing a Pioneer plasma. Do you have a recommendation on a possible equal to Pioneer Elite Plasma?

Scott Wilkinson's picture

Sadly, I know of no equal to the Pioneer Elite plasma. I used to say that the next best thing is a Panasonic plasma, but with its black-level problem, I can no longer say that. The last Samsung plasma reviewed by HT had fairly high black levels, and I've never been impressed with LG plasmas, so I honestly don't know where to turn for a good plasma. We'll keep looking...

james's picture

^ Sadly, I'd have to concur with Scott. Panasonic may have executed the most memorable "trippin on our own feet" incident the industry has seen in years with this dreadful move.Just when PDP could use a boost in the arm, it gets a shot in the foot.At least you could still enjoy the superior motion handling and off-axis viewing offered by a decent plasma. Whether the rising black levels are still nearly on par with COMPARABLY priced LCDs would be an interesting bit of info to know.My guess is that they'd be fairly close with all but the highest-end local-dimming LED models, but I could be in error with that assumption.Just noting there IS more to a display's performance than black level- although it is quite important to the critical viewer.what a dilemma!

steve's picture

One thing to consider if shopping for a plasma is what you're upgrading from. I recently upgraded from an old "flat screen" 180 Lb monster CRT that was only 30" in. to a Panasonic 46" in. G10 series plasma.I debated for a long time whether to go with Panasonic or not after reading about all the black level problems. Kuros are hard to find, and there aren't a lot of other options. In the end, I decided to go with the G10, rising black levels be damned, because I knew it would be such a vast improvement on my old TV. I got a great price and I'm thrilled with the result. For well under $1000, if I move this TV to a secondary system in a few years when there are some better Kuro-like options, I'm OK with that.Then again, I purposefully devoted the bulk of my budget to the audio side, so perhaps I'm just not a videophile...

Joel's picture

We have, in the past, used a Gefen 4x4 HDMI switcher or Key Digital component video switcher combined with an RTI or URC control system to achieve great success with "man cave" video walls. Strong recommendations for these manufacturers!

Ricky's picture

Panasonic black level issues? All the latest models I've seen (G20/25, VT20) have superb black levels; all way better than anything Samsung can offer. Also, the Sony 55HX701 is a great LCD. Some of the deepest blacks I've ever seen out of the box.

Frank's picture

Ricky, try googling "panasonic plasma black level problem" for starters. Out of the box, maybe, later, not so much??See also http://blog.ultimateavmag.com/scottwilkinson/calling_all_panny_owners/

Nolan Katz's picture

I went from a Hitatchi 57" CRT to a 58" Panasonic Plasma and I am completely satisfied. The Pioneer would have cost me twice as much.LED/LCD might be better for a bright room, but plasma is more natural in a semi-dark room.

Matt's picture

I recently purchased a samsung 58 inch 530 model. My main reason for doing so over panasonic was because of the black level problem with panasonic. If I am understanding the problem correctly ,it was the black levels readjust brighter after so many hours.I have been nothing but impressed with the picture quality of this tv. Black levels are superb. And there is not that annoying buzzing sound that alot of people have complained about the samsungs. I would definately recommend a samsung to anyone looking for a good plasma.

JJ's picture

It's sad when people buy into the hype about panasonic and it's "rising" black levels. I recently purchased an 54s10 and have run it for over 150 hours and noticed nothing. Still looks fantastic with the exception of the color inaccuracies which should soon be fixed with a calibration. I wonder how many people have actually seen these changes in the tv's and have made their decision on that. I looked at Samsung and LG and can honestly say my TV would have to rise an aweful lot to be worse then these brands plasmas. I know it may happen but I'm sure i'll still be happy. Paid 1700CDN and worth every penny.

Andrew's picture

KURO AT BEST BUY!Hey all,Just thought i would like to let some people know that if you live anywhere near the Detroit area they have multiple Pioneer Elite KuroPRO-101FDs available. That's the monitor and not the TV but they do throw in the stand :) It's only $2999 and last time i checked 3 weeks ago they said their distribution center had 54 of them! so if you can manage to do it or call them up the shipping might be worth it. I specifically talked to the Magnolia Southfield store.Good news, no? :)

Scott Wilkinson's picture

Great news, Andrew! The 101 is the 50-inch monitor, which is exactly the model I have in my home theater. (Sadly, I don't have enough room for the 60-incher.) Anyone contemplating a plasma purchase should definitely look into this!

Bill's picture

Ricky and JJ, welcome to the internet. Perhaps both of you should spend a little more time before voicing your opinions. The black level issue is there, and it may not show up right away when Scott and other reviewers are doing their reviews, but it can happen over time.and over 150 hours of viewing is not enough for your data to be calculated. people who have reported the increased black levels, are the ones usually north of maybe 600-700 hrs, from what I've seen. the problems are there, and even Panasonic came out and released a statement. perhaps you two gentlemen have the magic panasonic plasmas that were made by underground Pioneer 11G Kuro factory!

Tim's picture

In regard to the noise issue: I recently installed the Mitsubishi HC3800 in my home theater (first time PJer). I have a noise problem as well in the same dark, solid areas of the picture. This occurs even when the BD is paused, eleminating the conclusion that it could be film grain (there's a 'shimmy' as opposed to still distortion). My signal comes through a 25 foot, 22 AWG HDMI cable rated CL2 for in wall use. Unfortunately the most convienient installation involved my running the cable in conjunction with the 120V power cable through the same conduit (in addition to 5 channels of speaker wire). I believe this is the cause of my issue. Any ideas on how I can reduce the noise without significant cable seperation?

girls escorts London's picture

It is certainly interesting for me to read this article. Thanks for it. I like such topics and anything that is connected to this matter. I would like to read more soon. By the way, pretty nice design you have here, but don’t you think it should be changed from time to time?Sara Watcerson

sex indian lady's picture

It is certainly interesting for me to read the post. Thank author for it. I like such topics and everything connected to them. I would like to read more soon. Katty Pingtown

escort agency's picture

Pretty cool site to read it at least for me. I have a question, why haven't you you add that post to social bookmarking sites? That might bring rather big traffic to this page.

London brazilian escorts's picture

I definitely want to read more on that blog soon. BTW, rather good design you have at that blog, but don’t you think it should be changed from time to time?Megan William

pretty brunette girl's picture

It was very interesting for me to read this article. Thanks for it. I like such topics and everything connected to them. I would like to read a bit more on that blog soon.Bella Kuree

escort service geneva's picture

Keep on posting such articles. I like to read articles like this. Just add some pics :)

X